© 2014 SLODE Pte Ltd.
All Rights Reserved.
Spooned.
CATEGORIES

#64

GOOD, GREAT, OR GRAND CRU?

05 Aug 2014 By

Most people can’t tell plonk from grand cru; even experts have proven to be totally inconsistent. Does the science of wine-tasting remain an art?

By: The Observer

Every year Robert Hodgson selects the finest wines from his small California winery and puts them into competitions around the state.

And in most years, the results are surprisingly inconsistent: some whites rated as gold medallists in one contest do badly in another. Reds adored by some panels are dismissed by others. Over the decades Hodgson, a softly spoken retired oceanographer, became curious. Judging wines is by its nature subjective, but the awards appeared to be handed out at random.

So drawing on his background in statistics, Hodgson approached the organisers of the California State Fair wine competition, the oldest contest of its kind in North America, and proposed an experiment for their annual June tasting sessions.

Each panel of four judges would be presented with their usual “flight” of samples to sniff, sip and slurp. But some wines would be presented to the panel three times, poured from the same bottle each time. The results would be compiled and analysed to see whether wine testing really is scientific.

The first experiment took place in 2005. The last was in Sacramento earlier this month. Hodgson’s findings have stunned the wine industry. Over the years he has shown again and again that even trained, professional palates are terrible at judging wine.

“The results are disturbing,” says Hodgson from the Fieldbrook Winery in Humboldt County, described by its owner as a rural paradise. “Only about 10% of judges are consistent and those judges who were consistent one year were ordinary the next year.

“Chance has a great deal to do with the awards that wines win.”

Read More here

You might be interested in...

#420 No.

Sam Herde is The Man Who Has to Choose From Scores of Wines and Decide on The Special Ones That Make it Into Sunday Wine Down, PS.Cafe's Monthly Wine Tasting Series.

#98 No.

Find out what George Geris - New Zealand Winemaker of the Year - drinks when his own wines are not an option!